Skip to content

Prokaryote Vs Eukaryote Compare And Contrast Essays

This essay is an original work by Erk.
It does not necessarily reflect the views expressed in RationalWiki's Mission Statement, but we welcome discussion of a broad range of ideas.
Unless otherwise stated, this is original content, released under CC-BY-SA 3.0 or any later version. See RationalWiki:Copyrights.
Feel free to make comments on the talk page, which will probably be far more interesting, and might reflect a broader range of RationalWiki editors' thoughts.

I found this among some notes from undergrad that I was cleaning up. It's an answer from a test I wrote back in 2nd-year microbiology in 2001, and I think quite relevant as a primer on some biological concepts.

This essay explains:

  • Why there can exist a size difference between eukaryotes and prokaryotes
  • The minimal compliment of organelles required in a eukaryote
  • How prokaryotes carry out life without those organelles
  • How the endosymbiotic theory of eukaryotic evolution relates
  • The role of the cell wall in prokaryotes to water balance in the cell
  • The difference in the roles of the cell membrane between the two groups

Eukaryotes vs. Prokaryotes[edit]

In a eukaryotic organism, the membrane-bound organelles that are its trademark effectively raise the surface area-to-volume ratio, the traditional limit to cell size. In addition, they provide a high level of segregation and organisation for chemical reactions within the cell, arguably increasing efficiency and definitely increasing possible size. If environments are controlled by vacuoles and other organelles, reactions between reagents that would be too rare in the cytoplasm to react can be much faster, simply because the effective volume is smaller. Prokaryotes lack this ability, so in order for reactions involving low-concentration metabolites to occur, the cell must remain fairly small.

Eukaryotes require size for their diverse collection of structures. At the very least, a eukaryotic cell contains a nucleus, a membrane transport system including the endoplasmic reticulum and golgi, mitochondria, and the ever-present (and often transitory) vacuoles and vesicles. This arsenal requires quite a lot of space. Without so much cellular furniture to deal with, a prokaryote can afford to be the "bachelor's suite of life". As a case study, a single mitochondrion is roughly the size of a prokaryotic cell, and eukaryotes can have dozens of these. Mitochondria are, in fact, postulated as symbiotic prokaryotes adapted to life inside larger eukaryotic cells.

Their lack of dining set, chesterfield, and a china cabinet does not mean prokaryotes are less equipped to deal with survival, any less than a bachelor's suite is less condusive to survival than a three-bedroom apartment; in fact, they gain distinct advantages from their simplicity. The tiny prokaryote can do everything a eukaryote can do, and usually much faster. Their cellular membrane performs the ATP synthesis duties of a mitochondrion. DNA is constantly replicating in the bacterial cytoplasm, with neither the elegance nor the encumbrance of formal mitosis. The environment is small enough that reactions can occur in the hydrophilic cytoplasm or hydrophobic plasma membrane with satisfactory frequency. Some eukaryotic organisms, such as Paramecium, require a contractile vacuole to maintain water balance, while a bacterium achieves this passively with a semirigid cell wall that holds in hydrostatic pressure., keeping the cell from bursting. The eukaryotic membrane is little more than a transport region and a shield compared to the versatility of a prokaryote's, which produces ATP and acts as a hydrophobic environment as mentioned as well as anchoring the cell wall and chromosome and performing all the duties of a eukaryotic membrane.

Prokaryotic organisms are smaller and, in many ways, simpler than eukaryotes. This difference, however, could be likened to the difference between the terms "pen" and "ink-utilising cylindrical cone-tipped writing implement": one is certainly bigger, but size isn't everything.

 

Eukaryotic and Prokaryotic cells both have DNA as their geneticmaterial, are covered by a cell membrane, contain RNA, and are bothmade from the same basic chemical (carbohydrates, proteins, nucleicacid, minerals, fats, and vitamins). They both contain ribosomes.Eukaryotic cells contain large ribosomes and Prokaryotic cells containsmall ribosomes. Both of them also regulate the flow of the nutrientsand wastes that enter and leave them. Some other things they have incommon are they both have similar basic metabolism likephotosynthesis and reproduction. Eukaryotic and prokaryotic cellsrequire a supply of energy and are both highly regulated by elaboratesensing systems that make them aware of the reactions within themand the environment around them. They also both contain plasmamembranes. Eukaryotic cells have simple cilia and flagella whileprokaryotic cells have complex.As for the genetic material, prokaryotic cells do not have a truenucleus, are located within the cytoplasm, and are not bound by aspecial membrane. They also consist of a single molecule of DNA.Eukaryotic cells have a true nucleus, are located within the nucleus,and are bound by a double membrane-bound compartment within thecytoplasm. They also have numerous molecules of DNA combined withprotein, and are organized into chromosomes.Some prokaryotic cells have photosynthetic membranes arisingfrom the plasma membrane. Instead of having chromosomal DNA,prokaryotic cells genetic information is in a circular loop called aplasmid. They also have cell walls made up of peptidoglycan. Thesecells are represented by the domains Bacteria and Archaea.Prokaryotic cells are much smaller than eukaryotic cells, andsometimes contain a capsule. Prokaryotic cells contain three majortypes of shapes, such as, rod shaped, spherical, and spiral. Theorganisms within the prokaryotic cells are bacteria and cyanobacteria(also known as blue algae). Bacterial cells are about one to two um indiameter and ten um long. Unlike the eukaryotic cells, prokaryoticcells do not go through elaborate replication processes, bacterial cellsdivide by binary fission.Eukaryotic cells have a cytomembrane system of connectedmembrane structures and membrane bounded compartmentsspecialized to perform specific functions. They also contain theendomembrane system, which carries out a variety of tasks in the cell.Some of the tasks include synthesis of proteins and their transport intomembranes and organelles or out of the cell, metabolism andmovement of lipids, and detoxification of poisons. This system includesthe nuclear envelope, the endoplasmic reticulum, the Golgi apparatus,lysosomes, various kinds of vacuoles, and the plasma membrane. They also contain peroxisomes and chromosomes. These cells arerepresented by the kingdoms Protista, Fungi, Plantae, and Animalia.Eukaryotic cells are about ten times the size of prokaryotic cells.